Method note
How the Manager Readiness Assessment is scored
This page shows how each number in the team version of the Manager Readiness Assessment is worked out, for one person, for a team and for feedback from direct reports. The formulas and score ranges are here so you can follow how the results are calculated.
On this page: what it covers, the situations, one person's result, the team report, feedback from direct reports, what protects each person, what the result is and the limits.
What it covers
Seven areas of managing a team.
Each area is a part of the everyday work of leading people. The free assessment covers the first six. The team version adds the seventh, team trust and conflict. The order below is the order the scoring uses to break ties.
| Area | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Leadership mindset | Moving from doing the work yourself to leading the team. |
| Communication and direction | Helping employees understand priorities and what good work looks like. |
| Coaching and development | Helping your team learn, solve problems, and grow. |
| Feedback and accountability | Addressing issues early and fairly, and documenting what matters. |
| Delegation | Giving people responsibility for work and the authority to make decisions and follow through. |
| Time and priorities | Setting priorities and helping the team stay focused. |
| Team trust and conflict (team version only) | Building trust and dealing with friction early. |
The situations
35 situations, five in each area.
Each one asks which response is closest to what you would do.
- There are 35 situations, five for each of the seven areas. They come in a fixed order, area by area, with team trust and conflict last. The name of the area is shown above each situation.
- Each situation gives four ways to handle it. Each way reflects one of the four stages: Foundational, Developing, Established or Strong.
- The four ways appear in a random order for each situation, so the way with the most points is not always in the same place.
- There is no timer. The page says to allow about 15 to 20 minutes. The time is worked out from the length of the 35 situations and their choices, about 2,500 words, at 200 to 250 words a minute, with a few seconds to choose each answer.
- Scoring version 2026.11.2. Results from an earlier version of the situations are compared with this one by stage, not by number.
- You choose one way and the page moves to the next situation. The Back button returns you to an earlier situation, where you can choose again. Answering the last situation ends the assessment and shows the result, so go back before then if you want to change anything.
One person
How one person's result is worked out.
The same steps give the result on the screen and the stages in the personal report. They run on the person's own device.
What each way scores
Each way of handling a situation earns 4, 3, 2 or 1 points under TrueStep HR's scoring key, from the way that reflects the Strong stage down to the way that reflects the Foundational stage. The points are fixed in advance and are the same for everyone. They are never shown next to the choices.
Average each area
Each area has five situations. Add the five points and divide by five. The result is the area average, a number from 1 to 4. It moves in steps of 0.2, because it is made of five whole numbers.
Read the stage from the average
Use the cut points in the table below. Nothing is weighted, and no area counts more than another.
The overall stage
Add the seven area averages and divide by seven. Read the stage with the same cut points. The personal report shows this overall average to two decimals, so the number shown always agrees with the stage. Because every area has five situations, this equals the average of all 35 points.
Two practice examples
Two areas with lower averages supply the report examples. When scores tie, the report selects examples in the fixed area order. A manager can choose any area that fits their work. The score does not establish which exercise would help most.
What scored highest
Leave out the two areas already used for examples. Of the other areas, keep those at Established or Strong. Take up to two with the highest averages, again with the earlier area first when averages are equal. If no area qualifies, the report says that no area is at Established or Strong yet, and presents practice examples.
| Stage | Area average | Total of five |
|---|---|---|
| Strong | 3.5 or higher | 18 to 20 |
| Established | 2.6 or higher, below 3.5 | 13 to 17 |
| Developing | 1.6 or higher, below 2.6 | 8 to 12 |
| Foundational | Below 1.6 | 5 to 7 |
What the personal report says about each stage:
Worked example
One person, start to finish
The five points in each row are the points for that person's five situations in the area. The answers are invented for the example.
| Area | Points for the five situations | Average and stage |
|---|---|---|
| Leadership mindset | 4, 4, 3, 4, 3 (total 18) | 3.6, Strong |
| Communication and direction | 4, 3, 4, 3, 4 (total 18) | 3.6, Strong |
| Coaching and development | 4, 3, 4, 2, 3 (total 16) | 3.2, Established |
| Feedback and accountability | 2, 3, 2, 2, 2 (total 11) | 2.2, Developing |
| Delegation | 3, 2, 2, 2, 2 (total 11) | 2.2, Developing |
| Time and priorities | 2, 2, 3, 2, 2 (total 11) | 2.2, Developing |
| Team trust and conflict | 4, 4, 3, 4, 3 (total 18) | 3.6, Strong |
Now the overall stage, the two practice examples and what scored highest.
The team report
How the team report is worked out.
The team report uses only the seven area averages each person sends. It never sees an answer.
When the report opens
Collection ends when the response window closes (10 days unless extended), when every seat of the group is used, or as soon as the buyer closes it. The buyer can close it early only once 3 or more people have responded. The report opens once collection has ended and at least 3 responses have been received. With fewer than 3 there is no team view of any kind, not even a partial one.
Example: if collection ends with 4 responses the report opens. If collection ends with 2 responses there is no report.
What the report shows
With 3 or 4 responses the report shows the stage of each area and the overall stage only. It shows no averages, no count of people at each stage and no line on how scores vary. From 5 responses it shows averages to one decimal, the count of people at each stage and how scores vary.
Example: with 4 responses it shows the stage of each area and the overall stage only. With 5 responses it also shows averages, the count of people at each stage and how scores vary.
Team average for each area
Add every person's score for the area and divide by the number of people. From 5 responses the report shows it to one decimal. The team stage for the area is read from the average rounded to one decimal, with the same cut points as for a person, so a 2.6 is always Established. An average that falls exactly halfway between two tenths rounds up, and the report works this out with whole numbers, so a computer rounding error cannot change it.
Example: eight people score Leadership mindset 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.8 and 2.8. The sum is 21.2. 21.2 divided by 8 is 2.65, which is exactly halfway between 2.6 and 2.7. It rounds up, so the report shows 2.7.
The stage read from the average
The stage for an area is read from its team average to one decimal. The overall stage is read from the overall average to one decimal. Both use the same cut points as for a person. 3.5 or higher is Strong. 2.6 or higher and below 3.5 is Established. 1.6 or higher and below 2.6 is Developing. Below 1.6 is Foundational.
Example: an area average of 2.7 is Established. An area average of 3.5 is Strong, and an area average of 3.4 is Established. An overall average of 2.5 is Developing, and an overall average of 2.6 is Established.
The overall team stage
Add the seven area averages, before any rounding, and divide by seven. Round to one decimal and read the stage from that number.
People by stage
For each person, add their seven area scores and divide by seven. Read the stage with the same cut points, with no rounding. The report counts the people at each stage. It makes the same count for each area, from each person's score in that area. These counts appear only when 5 or more responses have been received.
The two highest scoring areas and the two areas to work on first
The two areas with the lowest team averages are the areas to work on first. Of the remaining areas, the two with the highest averages are the highest scoring. From 5 responses, areas are compared on their averages before rounding. With 3 or 4 responses the report shows no averages, so areas are compared by stage, and areas at the same stage tie. Ties go to the earlier area in the list of seven. If all seven areas tie, the report names no highest scoring areas and no areas to work on first, and says that all seven are at the same level. Highest scoring is relative: if every area is low, a highest scoring area can still be at Developing. The first step shown for each area to work on first is fixed text for that area. It is not calculated from the scores.
Example: four people give the same scores, which are 2.8, 3.0, 3.0, 3.0, 2.0, 2.0 and 3.4 in the order of the seven areas. With 4 responses, Delegation and Time and priorities are at Developing, so they are the two to work on first: Delegation and Time and priorities. The other five areas are all at Established, so they tie and the first two in the list are the two highest: Leadership mindset and Communication and direction. With 5 people giving the same scores, the averages are compared instead, and the two highest are Team trust and conflict and Communication and direction.
How scores vary in each area
How scores vary shows how much the scores for an area differ among respondents. It does not show whether people chose the same answer to any one situation. For each area the report takes the lowest score and the highest score among the people. The gap is the highest minus the lowest, on the 1 to 4 scale. The report names the gap with one of three words, shown in the table below. It shows the word from 5 responses. With 3 or 4 responses it does not show how scores vary.
Groups and sittings
A team can have more than one group. Each group has its own link or links, its own 10 day window and its own report. If seats are left over, the buyer can add another group. Each group has its own minimum of 3, and every number above is worked out from that group's people alone. Seats added to the team's pool can be given to a group that is still collecting, and responses on them count in that group's report. A group that has a report can be sat again. The new group is the next sitting of that group, and only one later sitting of a group can be open at a time. A comparison works best when the same managers respond both times. If people join or leave between sittings, the difference between the two reports can say something about them.
The roll up of groups
Several groups of one team in the same sitting can be rolled up into one report. A roll up uses only the groups that have 5 or more responses. Every response of those groups is pooled and averaged as one group: the average for an area is the sum of all the scores for that area divided by the number of responses, rounded to one decimal as above, and the stage is read from that number. The roll up also shows the overall average and stage, and the count of people at each stage. It lists each included group's own stages and averages beside the pooled ones. It does not show how scores vary. A roll up needs at least 2 eligible groups with 5 or more responses each. If those groups used different scoring versions, open their reports separately. A group with 3 or 4 responses is left out, and the report says how many responses are included out of all the responses of that sitting.
Example: one group of eight scores Leadership mindset 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.8 and 2.8. A group of five all score 3.0. Together the scores add up to 36.2. 36.2 divided by 13 responses is 2.78, which the report shows as 2.8. The stage is read from 2.8, so it is Established. If a third group in the same sitting has only 4 responses, it is left out, and the roll up says 13 of 17 responses are included.
Comparing two sittings
The report can compare two sittings of the same group. For each area and for the overall result, the difference is the later shown average minus the earlier shown average, to one decimal. A rise has a plus sign and a fall has a minus sign. A comparison needs 5 or more responses in both sittings. With fewer than 5 in either sitting, no comparison is shown. The two sittings may include different people, and people may remember the situations. Use a comparison to start a conversation, not as a measure of improvement.
Example: a first sitting shows 2.7 and the second sitting shows 3.0. The difference is +0.3. The report uses the averages as shown, so it does not use the exact 2.65. A fall has a minus sign: from 3.0 to 2.5 the difference is -0.5. A first sitting of 5 responses and a second sitting of 4 responses has no comparison.
The scoring version
The scoring version names the set of situations and points used to work out a result. It appears on a result as, for example, Scoring version 2026.11.2, on the screen and on the last page of the personal report. A team report keeps the scoring version of its responses. When the two sittings of a comparison have different scoring versions, the report shows the stage of each sitting and no average and no difference. Results of different scoring versions are compared by stage, not by number.
Example: a first sitting with scoring version 2026.11 and a second sitting with scoring version 2026.11.2 show stages only, with no average and no difference. Two sittings that both have scoring version 2026.11.2 show averages and differences.
| Word | The rule, applied to one area | What the report says |
|---|---|---|
| Wide | The gap between the lowest and the highest score is 2.0 or more. | Scores are far apart in this area. Ask the group what might explain the different views. |
| Mixed | The gap is 1.0 or more and below 2.0. | Scores vary in this area. Discuss what might explain the difference. |
| Consistent | The gap is below 1.0. | Scores are close together in this area. |
Worked example
A team of five
Each score is one person's average for the area, so the five scores in a row are five different people. The scores are invented for the example, in the same person order in every row.
| Area | Scores of person 1 to 5 | Team average, stage and how scores vary |
|---|---|---|
| Leadership mindset | 3.4, 3.6, 3.2, 3.4, 3.4 | 3.4, Established How scores vary: Consistent |
| Communication and direction | 3.0, 3.4, 2.8, 3.2, 3.6 | 3.2, Established How scores vary: Consistent |
| Coaching and development | 2.0, 2.2, 2.4, 2.2, 2.2 | 2.2, Developing How scores vary: Consistent |
| Feedback and accountability | 1.6, 2.2, 2.6, 2.0, 2.6 | 2.2, Developing How scores vary: Mixed |
| Delegation | 1.0, 1.4, 3.0, 3.6, 2.0 | 2.2, Developing How scores vary: Wide |
| Time and priorities | 2.2, 2.6, 3.0, 2.4, 2.6 | 2.6, Established How scores vary: Consistent |
| Team trust and conflict | 2.8, 3.0, 2.6, 3.2, 3.4 | 3.0, Established How scores vary: Consistent |
Two of the team numbers, worked out.
| Person | Seven area scores | Average and stage |
|---|---|---|
| Person 1 | 3.4, 3.0, 2.0, 1.6, 1.0, 2.2, 2.8 (total 16.0) | 2.29, Developing |
| Person 2 | 3.6, 3.4, 2.2, 2.2, 1.4, 2.6, 3.0 (total 18.4) | 2.63, Established |
| Person 3 | 3.2, 2.8, 2.4, 2.6, 3.0, 3.0, 2.6 (total 19.6) | 2.80, Established |
| Person 4 | 3.4, 3.2, 2.2, 2.0, 3.6, 2.4, 3.2 (total 20.0) | 2.86, Established |
| Person 5 | 3.4, 3.6, 2.2, 2.6, 2.0, 2.6, 3.4 (total 19.8) | 2.83, Established |
Now the people by stage, and the highest scoring areas and the areas to work on first.
Last, how scores vary: one example for each word.
Delegation has the same average as Coaching and development and Feedback and accountability, yet it is the most divided area. That is why the report shows how scores vary beside every average. The other five areas are Consistent: the gap is below 1.0 in each.
Feedback from direct reports
How the feedback is worked out.
A manager can ask the people who report to them to answer fourteen short statements. The feedback is shown only on that manager's private feedback page.
What each person answers
Each direct report answers fourteen statements, two for each area, with Almost never, Rarely, Sometimes, Often, Almost always or I do not have enough information. Almost never counts 1, Rarely 2, Sometimes 3, Often 4 and Almost always 5. I do not have enough information is not counted and its number is never shown.
How each area's frequency label is worked out
For each area, every counted answer to its two statements is pooled and averaged, with no rounding first. Under 1.5 the word is Almost never, under 2.5 Rarely, under 3.5 Sometimes, under 4.5 Often, and otherwise Almost always.
Example: an area has 5 counted answers on its first statement (4, 4, 3, 5, 4) and 4 on its second (3, 3, 4, 2). The sum is 20 + 12 = 32. 32 divided by 9 is 3.56, which is not under 3.5 and is under 4.5, so the word is Often.
Statements with few answers
A statement with fewer than 3 counted answers is left out of its area. An area that rests on one statement says Based on one of the two statements. If both statements are left out it says Fewer than 3 usable answers.
Example: an area's first statement has 2 counted answers and its second has 6. The first is left out, so the area rests on the second and says Based on one of the two statements. If both had fewer than 3, the area would say Fewer than 3 usable answers.
When anything is shown
Combined feedback is released when the form closes with at least 3 responses. Response totals appear as 3 or 4, 5 to 7, or 8 or more. With 8 or more responses, each statement with at least 3 usable answers also shows its own frequency label.
What protects each person
What is sent, what is kept, and who sees it.
Here is what the assessment sends, stores and shows.
What the result is
How to use the result.
The result is a guide for development conversations. It shows how a person says they would handle everyday situations of managing a team, grouped into four stages, so that a person or a team has somewhere to start.
It is not a validated test. The points are a judgment, not a measurement. There is no reference group of other managers or employers. The results show this group of written choices only, so they should not be used to rank people.
General background on situational judgment questions and maturity stages is in the reference note, How situational judgment assessments work. It is background on the method. It does not report results for these 35 situations.
Limits
What to keep in mind when you read a result.
- The situations and their points reflect TrueStep HR's own judgment of sound management practice.
- Five situations per area is a small sample. An area stage is a starting point for a conversation, not a measurement of a person.
- Each situation asks which response is closest to what you would do. A person can choose the way they think is best, not the way they would act. The assessment cannot tell the difference.
- The points for each way are fixed in advance. They are a judgment, not a measurement, and reasonable managers may disagree about some of them.
- The cut points are sharp. An average of 2.6 is Established and an average of 2.4 is Developing, though the two people may be close.
- Scores are worked out on the person's device. The service checks that each score is within range, but cannot check how it was reached.
- A result is a snapshot of one sitting. It can change when a person takes the assessment again, and no figure on this page says by how much.
- A team average hides differences. That is why how scores vary is shown, and why two areas with the same average can need different conversations.
- Nothing checks who took the assessment. A group link is shared and not tied to named people. In a Shared group each personal link is filed under the name it was made for, and a forwarded link counts for that name. At least 3 responses are required. That minimum does not guarantee that individuals cannot be inferred, even when all 3 responses come from different people. Anyone with the link can respond, up to the seats of the group, and on a group link the same person on two devices counts twice.
- A team report needs at least 3 responses, but 3 is not a promise that nobody can be recognized. In a team of 3 or 4, the report shows the stage of each area and the overall stage only, with no averages, no count of people at each stage and no line on how scores vary, but colleagues in so small a team may still be able to guess who is who.
Questions
Ask us.
If a step here is unclear, or you work it out and get a different number, email support@truestephr.com.
Related pages: the team assessment, the free Manager Readiness Assessment and how our other assessments are scored.